search menu flickr twitter phone angle-left angle-right angle-up angle-down file-pdf link-ext doc-inv sitemap location map calendar credit-card clock facebook-squared minus plus cancel ok instagramm download inkwell

NTSB Finds Inadequate Safeguards in Place for Self-Driving Vehicle Testing Across U.S.

Nov 21, 2019

Corinne Kisner, Executive Director of the National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO), issued the following statement in response to NTSB’s call for more stringent AV testing standards:

NACTO applauds NTSB for its focus on the systemic causes behind the death of Elaine Herzburg, who was struck by an Uber self-driving SUV in March 2018. NACTO urges all policymakers to immediately work to correct what NTSB found: a negligent safety culture at Uber and chronic inaction on the part of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), which is responsible for autonomous vehicle safety across the country.

During the hearing, NTSB determined that Uber had callously ignored safety, lacking even the most basic standards to ensure safety when testing autonomous vehicles. Uber had no plan in place to address driver inattention and complacency, a well-known issue with repetitive driving, especially in an automated scenario. Compounding this mistake, the company had no defined safety plan, even though it knew that its self-driving system did not reliably detect pedestrians outside of crosswalks.

However, Uber’s missteps, while careless and ultimately fatal, did not occur in a vacuum. As emphasized by NTSB, there are virtually no federal safety standards, and few state standards, for AV testing in the United States. NACTO echoes NTSB’s recommendations to NHTSA and States to establish comprehensive safety standards for AVs and evaluate companies’ safety performance before permitting testing on public streets. It is not enough to request voluntary safety reports, often amounting to little more than “marketing brochures” in the words of one NTSB investigator.

We cannot afford for the institutions tasked with keeping streets safe to stay hands-off (or “laughably lax”, as an NTSB board member put it) when it comes to AV technology. The absence of federal leadership, including mandatory safety standards, contributes to an inherently risky and unaccountable AV testing environment.

If they are developed, programmed, and rigorously tested with the safety of people outside and inside of the vehicle held as the paramount goal, AVs can theoretically make our streets much safer. But, this outcome is impossible without clear safety standards and strong regulations from the institutions responsible for protecting everyone on our streets.


About the National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO)
NACTO is an association of 81 major North American cities and transit agencies formed to exchange transportation ideas, insights, and practices and cooperatively approach national transportation issues. The organization’s mission is to build cities as places for people, with safe, sustainable, accessible, and equitable transportation choices that support a strong economy and vibrant quality of life. To learn more, visit or follow us on Twitter at @NACTO.

Alexander Engel | [email protected] | 646.324.2919

For further background on NACTO’s positions on autonomous vehicles, see the Blueprint for Autonomous Urbanism